Miss Indiana USA 2024 – Stephanie Sullivan
1st runner-up – Audrey Schlegel (1RU 23)
2nd runner-up – Abby Foster (4RU IL USA 23, 1RU 22, 1RU 21, 2RU 20, Miss IL 17, 2RU IL TUSA 14)
3rd runner-up – Meagan Crews Jenkins (Miss LA 19)
4th runner-up – Yana Jones
5th runner-up – KK Kokonaing (IN TUSA 22)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2024 – Aleah Dean (1RU 23, 4RU 22)
1st runner-up – Beverly Lopez
2nd runner-up – Summer Ratcliffe
3rd runner-up – JJ Kokonaing
4th runner-up – Jetta Hayes
5th runner-up – Sophia Hunt
Miss Indiana USA 2017 – Brittany Winchester (2RU 16, 4RU 15)
1st runner-up – Darrian Arch (1RU 16, IN TUSA 13) [later Miss IN USA 2018]
2nd runner-up – Kelsey White (2RU KY USA 16, SF 15, SF 14, SF 11)
3rd runner-up – Ashley Paddock (SF IN TUSA 11)
4th runner-up – Victoria Brown
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2017 – Paige Robinson
1st runner-up – Meera Gupta (2RU CT TUSA 16)
2nd runner-up – Sadie Welch
3rd runner-up – Ella Harrison [later Miss IN Teen USA 2018]
4th runner-up – Kaylee Gardner (SF 16)
Miss Indiana USA 2014 – Mekayla Diehl (SF 13)
1st runner-up – Destiny Dever (3RU 13, SF KY USA 12, 4RU 11, 3RU 10)
2nd runner-up – Alexis Ginn
3rd runner-up – Samantha Steffen (T10 CA USA 12)
4th runner-up – Jillian Scholten
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2014 – Amanda Armstrong (2RU 13, 2RU 12)
1st runner-up – Rachelle Kassebnia
2nd runner-up – Alexandra Dallas
3rd runner-up – Channing Gappens
4th runner-up – Madison Boldry (1RU 13, 2RU 12)
Miss Indiana USA 2013 – Emily Hart (1RU 12, 3RU 11, 2RU 10)
1st runner-up – Morgan Abel (2RU 12, IN TUSA 08) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
2nd runner-up – Nicole Pollard (3RU 12, Miss IN 09)
3rd runner-up – Destiny Dever (SF KY USA 12, 4RU 11, 3RU 10)
4th runner-up – Rohma Siddiqui (SF 12, SF 10, SF IN TUSA 09)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2013 – Darrian Arch [later Miss IN USA 2018]
1st runner-up – Madison Boldry (2RU 12)
2nd runner-up – Zoe Parker [later Miss IN Teen USA 2014]
3rd runner-up – Mariah Scott (3RU 12)
4th runner-up – Toree Brown
Miss Indiana USA 2012 – Megan Myrehn (VA TUSA 08, SF 06)
1st runner-up – Emily Hart (3RU 11, 2RU 10) [later Miss IN USA 2013]
2nd runner-up – Morgan Abel (IN TUSA 08) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
3rd runner-up – Nicole Pollard (Miss IN 09)
4th runner-up – Whitney Hatter (1RU 11, 3RU 10)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2012 – Mackenzie Surber (3RU 11)
1st runner-up – Abigail Luther
2nd runner-up – Madison Boldry
3rd runner-up – Mariah Scott
4th runner-up – Allison Walter (NF 11)
1st runner-up – Tiffany Mack (4RU 09, SF 08, SF 07)
2nd runner-up – Emily Hart [later Miss IN USA 2013]
3rd runner-up – Whitney Hatter
4th runner-up – Christina DeVoe (SF IL USA 08, 1RU IL TUSA 04, SF 03)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2010 – Madeline Plesac
1st runner-up – Brittany Hood (1RU 09, 4RU 08)
2nd runner-up – Megan Thwaites
3rd runner-up – Kate Raaen (3RU 09)
4th runner-up – Sylvia Crowder
Miss Indiana USA 2009 –
1st runner-up – Jessica Billings (SF MN USA 07, SF MN TUSA 05, T6 04) [later Miss PA USA 2013]
2nd runner-up – Allison Biehle (SF 08) [later Miss IN USA 2010]
3rd runner-up – Melyssa Ramos (2RU 08, 4RU 07, IN TUSA 02)
4th runner-up – Tiffany Mack (SF 08, SF 07)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2009 – Bailee ZimmermanÂ
1st runner-up – Brittany Hood (4RU 08)
2nd runner-up – Jessica Karle (SF 08)
3rd runner-up – Kate Raaen
4th runner-up – Krista Boynton (SF 07, SF 06)
Miss Indiana USA 2008 – Brittany Mason
1st runner-up – Megan Bailey (1RU 07 3RU 06, SF 05)
2nd runner-up – Melyssa Ramos (4RU 07, IN TUSA 02)
3rd runner-up – Emily Dawson (SF 07)
4th runner-up – Crystal Hill
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2008 – Morgan Abel* (1RU 07) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
1st runner-up – Hannah Clingan
2nd runner-up – Emilee Hayden
3rd runner-up – Jayla Lawrence
4th runner-up – Brittany Hood
Miss Indiana USA 2006 –
1st runner-up – Katy Serwoka (SF 05)
2nd runner-up – Tiffany Schroer (1RU 04, 1RU IN TUSA 03, SF IN TUSA 02)
3rd runner-up – Megan Bailey (SF 05)
4th runner-up – Katherine Cain (4RU 05)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2006 – Halley Wallace
1st runner-up – Jessica Ritchie
2nd runner-up – Christina Keneipp
3rd runner-up – Brittany Clute (4RU 05)
4th runner-up – Victoria Tomlinson (3RU 05, 4RU 04) [later Miss IN Teen USA 2007]
Miss Indiana USA 2024 – Stephanie Sullivan
1st runner-up – Audrey Schlegel (1RU 23)
2nd runner-up – Abby Foster (4RU IL USA 23, 1RU 22, 1RU 21, 2RU 20, Miss IL 17, 2RU IL TUSA 14)
3rd runner-up – Meagan Crews Jenkins (Miss LA 19)
4th runner-up – Yana Jones
5th runner-up – KK Kokonaing (IN TUSA 22)
Miss Indiana USA 2017 – Brittany Winchester (2RU 16, 4RU 15)
1st runner-up – Darrian Arch (1RU 16, IN TUSA 13) [later Miss IN USA 2018]
2nd runner-up – Kelsey White (2RU KY USA 16, SF 15, SF 14, SF 11)
3rd runner-up – Ashley Paddock (SF IN TUSA 11)
4th runner-up – Victoria Brown
Miss Indiana USA 2014 – Mekayla Diehl (SF 13)
1st runner-up – Destiny Dever (3RU 13, SF KY USA 12, 4RU 11, 3RU 10)
2nd runner-up – Alexis Ginn
3rd runner-up – Samantha Steffen (T10 CA USA 12)
4th runner-up – Jillian Scholten
Miss Indiana USA 2013 – Emily Hart (1RU 12, 3RU 11, 2RU 10)
1st runner-up – Morgan Abel (2RU 12, IN TUSA 08) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
2nd runner-up – Nicole Pollard (3RU 12, Miss IN 09)
3rd runner-up – Destiny Dever (SF KY USA 12, 4RU 11, 3RU 10)
4th runner-up – Rohma Siddiqui (SF 12, SF 10, SF IN TUSA 09)
Miss Indiana USA 2012 – Megan Myrehn (VA TUSA 08, SF 06)
1st runner-up – Emily Hart (3RU 11, 2RU 10) [later Miss IN USA 2013]
2nd runner-up – Morgan Abel (IN TUSA 08) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
3rd runner-up – Nicole Pollard (Miss IN 09)
4th runner-up – Whitney Hatter (1RU 11, 3RU 10)
1st runner-up – Tiffany Mack (4RU 09, SF 08, SF 07)
2nd runner-up – Emily Hart [later Miss IN USA 2013]
3rd runner-up – Whitney Hatter
4th runner-up – Christina DeVoe (SF IL USA 08, 1RU IL TUSA 04, SF 03)
Miss Indiana USA 2008 – Brittany Mason
1st runner-up – Megan Bailey (1RU 07 3RU 06, SF 05)
2nd runner-up – Melyssa Ramos (4RU 07, IN TUSA 02)
3rd runner-up – Emily Dawson (SF 07)
4th runner-up – Crystal Hill
Miss Indiana USA 2006 –
1st runner-up – Katy Serwoka (SF 05)
2nd runner-up – Tiffany Schroer (1RU 04, 1RU IN TUSA 03, SF IN TUSA 02)
3rd runner-up – Megan Bailey (SF 05)
4th runner-up – Katherine Cain (4RU 05)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2024 – Aleah Dean (1RU 23, 4RU 22)
1st runner-up – Beverly Lopez
2nd runner-up – Summer Ratcliffe
3rd runner-up – JJ Kokonaing
4th runner-up – Jetta Hayes
5th runner-up – Sophia Hunt
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2017 – Paige Robinson
1st runner-up – Meera Gupta (2RU CT TUSA 16)
2nd runner-up – Sadie Welch
3rd runner-up – Ella Harrison [later Miss IN Teen USA 2018]
4th runner-up – Kaylee Gardner (SF 16)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2014 – Amanda Armstrong (2RU 13, 2RU 12)
1st runner-up – Rachelle Kassebnia
2nd runner-up – Alexandra Dallas
3rd runner-up – Channing Gappens
4th runner-up – Madison Boldry (1RU 13, 2RU 12)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2013 – Darrian Arch [later Miss IN USA 2018]
1st runner-up – Madison Boldry (2RU 12)
2nd runner-up – Zoe Parker [later Miss IN Teen USA 2014]
3rd runner-up – Mariah Scott (3RU 12)
4th runner-up – Toree Brown
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2012 – Mackenzie Surber (3RU 11)
1st runner-up – Abigail Luther
2nd runner-up – Madison Boldry
3rd runner-up – Mariah Scott
4th runner-up – Allison Walter (NF 11)
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2010 – Madeline Plesac
1st runner-up – Brittany Hood (1RU 09, 4RU 08)
2nd runner-up – Megan Thwaites
3rd runner-up – Kate Raaen (3RU 09)
4th runner-up – Sylvia Crowder
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2008 – Morgan Abel* (1RU 07) [later Miss IN USA 2016]
1st runner-up – Hannah Clingan
2nd runner-up – Emilee Hayden
3rd runner-up – Jayla Lawrence
4th runner-up – Brittany Hood
Miss Indiana Teen USA 2006 – Halley Wallace
1st runner-up – Jessica Ritchie
2nd runner-up – Christina Keneipp
3rd runner-up – Brittany Clute (4RU 05)
4th runner-up – Victoria Tomlinson (3RU 05, 4RU 04) [later Miss IN Teen USA 2007]