MISS INDIANA TEEN USA TITLEHOLDERS
​>> competing in Miss USA & Miss state pageants

This page details the Miss Indiana Teen USA titleholders who have competed at Miss USA or competed in Miss USA state pageants.  Click here for a full listing of Miss IN USA & Teen USA titleholders.

Seven Miss Indiana Teen USA titleholders have competed at Miss USA, all representing their home state. The most successful at Miss USA was Kelly Lloyd (93), one of only a few contestants to make the top five at both Miss Teen USA and Miss USA. Kelly is also well known for being one of a small group of Triple Crown winners who has competed at Miss Teen USA, Miss USA and Miss America. The most recent former Teen to win a state title was Courtni Hall (2004).
Former Teens competing in Miss - by state
Alabama | Alaska | Arizona | Arkansas | California | Colorado | Connecticut | Delaware | District of Columbia | Florida
Georgia | Hawaii | Idaho | Illinois | Indiana | Iowa | Kansas | Kentucky | Louisiana | Maine | Maryland | Massachusetts
Michigan | Minnesota | Mississippi | Missouri | Montana | Nebraska | Nevada | New Hampshire | New Jersey | New Mexico
New York | North Carolina | North Dakota | Ohio | Oklahoma | Oregon | Pennsylvania | Rhode Island | South Carolina
South Dakota | Tennessee | Texas | Utah | Vermont | Virginia | Washington | West Virginia | Wisconsin | Wyoming

Miss IN Teen USA titleholders who have competed at Miss USA (8)

1991 - Heather Hart (Semi-finalist) - Miss Indiana USA 1995
1992 - Nicole Llewellyn (Semi-finalist) - Miss Indiana USA 1998
1993 - Kelly Lloyd (1st runner-up) - Miss Indiana USA 2002 (2nd runner-up at Miss USA) (Triple Crown winner)
1995 - Sarah McClary - Miss Indiana USA 2001
1998 - Tashina Kastigar - Miss Indiana USA 2003 (Semi-finalist at Miss USA)
2003 - Jami Stallings (Top 15) - Miss Indiana USA 2007
2004 - Courtni Hall - Miss Indiana USA 2009 
2008 - Morgan Abel - Miss Indiana USA 2016
2013 - Darrian Arch - Miss Indiana USA 2018
Picture
Heather Hart | 1991 (SF) & 1995
Picture
Nicole Llewellyn | 1992 (SF) & 1998
Picture
Kelly Lloyd | 1993 (1RU) & 2002 (2RU)
Picture
Sarah McClary | 1995 & 2001
Picture
Tashina Kastigar | 1998 & 2003 (SF)
Picture
Jami Stallings | 2003 (T15) & 2007
Picture
Courtni Hall | 2004 & 2009
Picture
Morgan Abel | 2008 & 2016
Picture
Darrian Arch | 2013 & 2018

Participation in Miss USA state pageants (13)

1991 - Heather Hart (Semi-finalist) - Miss Indiana USA 1995
1992 - Nicole Llewellyn (Semi-finalist) - 3RU IN USA 1997, Miss Indiana USA 1998
1993 - Kelly Lloyd (1st runner-up) - Miss Indiana USA 2002
1994 - Nicolette Van Hook  - 2RU IN USA 1999, 2RU 2000, SF 2001, 2RU 2002
1995 - Sarah McClary - Miss Indiana USA 2001
1997 - Amber Yoder - 1RU IN USA 2003, 2RU 2004, 3RU 2005
1998 - Tashina Kastigar - Miss Indiana USA 2003
2002 - Melyssa Ramos - 4RU IN USA 2007, 2RU 2008, 3RU 2009
2003 - Jami Stallings (Top 15) - Miss Indiana USA 2007
2004 - Courtni Hall - SF IN USA 2007, SF IN USA 2008, Miss Indiana USA 2009
2008 - Morgan Abel - 2RU IN USA 2012, 1RU 2013, SF 2014, 2RU 2015, ​Miss Indiana USA 2016
2009 - Bailee Zimmerman - T20 NY USA 2012, NF IN USA 2015, SF NY USA 2018, NF 2019, 3RU IN USA 2020
2013 - Darrian Arch - 1RU IN USA 2016, 1RU 2017, Miss Indiana USA 2018
Most recent competition photos for each delegate (where available):
Picture
02 Melyssa Ramos | 3RU IN USA 2009
Picture
03 Jami Stallings | Miss IN USA 2007
Picture
04 Courtni Hall | Miss IN USA 2009
Picture
08 Morgan Abel | Miss IN USA 2016
Picture
09 Bailee Zimmerman | NF IN USA 2015
Picture
13 Darrian Arch | 1RU IN USA 2017

The following Teens are still eligible (as far as I am aware)

2009 - Bailee Zimmerman
2010 - Madeline Plesac
2011 - Jessica Buch (Semi-finalist)
2012 - Mackenzie Surber
2014 - Zoe Parker (Semi-finalist)
2015 - Kassidy Tharp
2016 - Lauren Boswell
2017 - Paige Robinson (3rd runner-up)